Go Into The Story Interview (Part 3): Katla Sólnes

Go Into The Story Interview (Part 3): Katla Sólnes

Katla Sólnes wrote the original screenplay Eruption which won a 2025-2026 Nicholl Fellowship in Screenwriting. I had an hour-long conversation with Katla exploring her creative background, analyzing her Nicholl-winning screenplay, and a discussion of key aspects of the screenwriting craft.

Today in Part 3, Katla dives deeper into her Nicholl-winning screenplay Eruption as she talks about the third principal character in the story and dynamic tension between them all.


Scott: As Joseph Campbell says, "The journey the hero or heroine," in this case, “takes is the journey they need to take." And that journey really begins when this third character shows up: Jane. Here’s how you describe her introduction in the script;

"A young woman with long blonde hair backlit by the hazy evening sun carefully steps out of the car. She wears jeans and a plunging V-neck sweater, aggressively '70s. This is Jane." And it says, " Elín stares at her stunned." They were expecting a guy.

Katla: Yes.

Scott: Let's talk about Jane.

Katla: Every year, they vet the people who apply and Elín chooses the best person for the job. And this year, the best person for the job very purposely hid the fact that they're a woman and this is a classic sort of story trope, let's say, but it's one that I love. I love the woman pretending to be a man. There's just something very magical about that. So, of course, her arrival is shocking not because she's young or beautiful or intelligent though all these things become big annoyances to Elín, but the first shock is just that she's a woman.

Jane is an interesting character because she's very ambitious, she's driven and she very much personifies the kind of go-getter women of that era. You need to play the game and so she does. She's a lot more brazen than women of Elín's age, even though it's only a generation between them. Those years count for a huge change in their ability to move through the world and their confidence in moving through the world.

Scott: To me, if you think in terms of a character archetype, Jane is a Trickster. Right off the bat, the way she submits her application with initials, and so we don't know she’s a woman. Trying to navigate a patriarchal, misogynist world of science, as a geologist, right?

Katla: Because we're so entrenched in Elín's point of view for the entirety of the film, I think the way she sees her is how we see her, which is a very unpredictable woman, almost frighteningly so. Jane has been in the science field for her short, but still relevant adult life. So, I think she's very well equipped at navigating these kinds of old farts, let's say, who don't believe in her, and she knows all the tricks to get them to like her whether she uses her feminine wiles as much as she uses her actual intelligence, enthusiasm and ambition.

And I think at first, she doesn't really know what to do with Elín because she's not really used to having to schmooze a woman in this way, so especially in the first act, the two women butt heads because they don't understand each other

Scott: Elín is a gatekeeper to her husband.

 Katla: Yes, exactly.

Scott: And because Kári is injured, old, and his famous book came out a long time ago, he's concerned about being kind of a relic. There's a theme or dynamic of impotence at work in the beginning of the story. Every time he reaches out to Elín as an overture to sex…

Katla: Yeah.

Scott: She'll find some reason to say “no.” We get this idea that the couple is at sixes and sevens in terms of their intimacy. So, there's some sexual tension when Jane shows up. She's in the tradition of the femme fatale.

Katla: Totally.

Scott: But the thing that's so interesting about her is that every time she does something that feels like she’s using her sexuality, she has a reason that she explains her behavior.

Katla: Many of her, let's say more unsavory deeds, by virtue of her youth and her ambition, she's a little selfish … as one can be. But I think Jane truly tries to do the right thing and has her own sense of logic of why that is the right thing. I don't know how spoiler heavy we're allowed to go but, with the conference and with Elín's discovery in the third act, both of these things, Jane is trying to help herself, but also Elín in her own strange way.

Scott: I want to step outside the story for a bit and talk screenwriter to screenwriter. I’m reading your script and Jane shows up on page 16, the midpoint of Act One. Then later, Elín, who has declined to go with her husband, after Jane shows up and Elín becomes suspicious, even jealous, she declares she is going to accompany the pair on their expedition. That happens right at the end of Act One.

Katla: Definitely.

Scott: This is a character piece, yet the story structure reads like conventional Hollywood storytelling, three-act structure… and I’m not saying that’s a bad thing, just an observation. Could you talk about your approach to story structure?

Katla: I had an understanding of story prior to going to grad school, and also just by loving film, but Columbia is very much into what we call the eight sequences method. Based on how film reels were 12 minutes, thus generally two reels (or sequences) in the first act, four in the second and two in the third. And each sequence should have its own story, drive, force, climax. And you put that into the three-act structure. So, that's the method that we're taught, and a method I very much resonated with because even though I like, let's say, operatic landscapes and visuals and messy characters, I love a well-structured tale.

I'm a bit of a screenwriting nerd now, both coming from Columbia and also teaching screenwriting there and at a pre-college program at Northwestern. So, I teach my students the three-act structure.

It also helps me beat out the story because when I sat down and wrote that monstrous draft, it's not as if I was just going from instinct purely. For months, I’ll have been thinking about the story. For instance, I'm writing two scripts right now, and I'm more often thinking about them than writing them.

But once that reflection is done, usually the first step I do is an outline, and in that outline I will always make sure to beat out the inciting incident, the end of Act One, especially the midpoint, which is crucial, and so on. And then of course these things develop once you write the script and things are working differently than you anticipated, but I'm very much a structure nerd in, in my process and in how I engage with film.

Scott: The thing that I was interested to hear you say, that once you landed on those three characters and knocked out that 160 plus page script, you felt them, you saw them. You did a lot more work once you went to Sundance and so forth. That's the difference between that sort of outside-in approach, “Let's have these events happen on this page or that,” versus an inside-out approach where the characters drive the story-crafting process.

Katla: Exactly.


Tomorrow in Part 4, Katla talks about the sexual tension between the three lead characters and the "tectonic plates" shifting underneath the characters.

For Part 1 of the interview series, go here.

Part 2, here.

I have interviewed every Nicholl winner since 2012. You may read those interviews here: LINK.